Troubleshooting

Water Heater Leaking? What to Do Right Now

Stop the water first, then find where it is coming from. Where the leak starts tells you if it is a small repair or a tank that is done.

R
Rob
Owner & Master Plumber
November 16, 20266 min read

Water on the floor right now? Shut the water off, then call us.

Call 484-902-2111
Two Plumb it Heat it Cool it plumbers smiling next to a water heater
Our plumbers on a water heater job in a local basement.

First: Stop the Water (2 Minutes)

Nobody wants to find a puddle under the water heater. Do these three things before anything else. They stop the leak from getting worse, and they are safe for any homeowner to do.

  • Turn off the water going into the tank. Look for the pipe on top marked cold. It has a handle on it. Turn a lever a quarter turn so it sits across the pipe, or turn a round handle to the right until it stops.
  • Turn off the heat. On a gas water heater, turn the dial on the front to OFF. On an electric one, flip the water heater breaker off at your electric panel.
  • Move anything that can be ruined. Boxes, rugs and stored items soak up water fast. Put a bucket or towels where the water is landing.

Where Is the Water Coming From?

Dry the tank off with a towel and watch where the water shows up again. The spot tells you almost everything.

  • From the top: Usually a loose pipe connection or a worn shutoff valve. This is a repair, not a new water heater. Water from the top runs down the side, so it can look like a bottom leak. Check the top first.
  • From the side pipe with a little lever: That is the safety valve. It opens when the pressure or heat inside the tank gets too high. A drip here means the valve is worn, or the pressure in your house is too high. Both can be fixed. Do not cap or plug this pipe. It is what keeps the tank safe.
  • From the spout near the bottom: That is the drain. Sometimes it just needs to be tightened or replaced. Small job.
  • From under the tank itself: The steel tank inside has rusted through. This cannot be patched. The water heater needs to be replaced.

What Happens If You Leave It

A leak from the tank itself does not heal. It starts as a slow drip and gets bigger as the rust spreads. The tank is connected to your water line, so if it opens up, the water does not stop at 40 or 50 gallons. It keeps coming until someone shuts it off.

Picture coming home from work or a weekend away to an inch of water across the basement floor. Now it is not a water heater job. It is wet drywall, ruined carpet, fans running for days and a call to your insurance company. Catching it at the drip stage is the cheap version of this problem.

Water on the floor right now?

Shut the water off, then call. We find the leak, show you where it is, and give you the whole price before any work starts.

Call 484-902-2111Book Online

Repair or Replace?

Leaks at the top, the safety valve or the drain can usually be repaired, and we will tell you so. You only hear about a new water heater from us when that is the best option.

Replacement makes sense when the tank itself is leaking, or when the water heater is past 10 years old and showing rust. If a tank died young, we also check the water pressure in your house. High pressure is hard on a tank, and putting a new one on the same pressure just starts the clock again.

Who to Call for a Leaking Water Heater

Call a licensed plumber. A water heater has water, pressure and either gas or high-voltage power, so it is plumber work, not handyman work.

We are a family-owned plumbing company serving Montgomery and Bucks County. We find where the leak is coming from, show you, and give you the whole price before any work starts. If it can be repaired, we repair it.

Rob and Rachel, owners of Plumb it Heat it Cool it

Hi, we are Rob and Rachel.

We own Plumb it Heat it Cool it, a family-owned company serving Montgomery and Bucks County. Nobody likes calling a plumber. When you call us, we find the problem, show it to you, and give you the whole price before any work starts.

Call 484-902-2111Book Online

Related Services

Water Heater ServicesEmergency Plumbing
FAQ

Common Questions

If water is coming from under the tank, treat it as urgent. Shut off the water and the heat, then call a plumber the same day. A drip from a pipe on top or from the safety valve can usually wait for a normal appointment once the water is off.

Not if the tank itself is leaking. Keep the water and the heat turned off until a plumber looks at it. Leaving it on keeps pressure on a tank that is already failing.

There are three common causes: the drain spout is loose or worn, water is running down from a leak higher up, or the tank has rusted through. Dry it off and watch where the water comes back. Water from under the tank means the tank has failed.

No. Once the steel tank rusts through, there is no safe patch. Leaks at the pipe connections, the safety valve and the drain can be fixed.

Yes, once the heat is off. If you smell gas, leave the house and call your gas company from outside. If water is near an electric water heater or an outlet, turn the breaker off before you step in the water.

Keep Reading

Related Articles

Buying Guides

When to Replace a Water Heater: 6 Signs It Is Time

Most tank water heaters last 8 to 12 years. Here are the six signs that yours is near the end, and when a repair is still the right call.

Read more
Cost Guides

How Much Does It Cost to Replace a Water Heater in Montgomery County? (2026 Guide)

Understand what drives water heater replacement costs in Montgomery and Bucks County, including 40-gallon vs 50-gallon sizing, tank vs tankless, installation factors, and how to get an accurate quote.

Read more
Troubleshooting

No Hot Water? Why Your Water Heater Is Not Working

Three safe checks for a gas water heater and two for an electric one, what each one means, and the point where it is time to call.

Read more
Ready?

Schedule Your Service Today

Whether it's an emergency or routine maintenance, our team is ready. Book online in 30 seconds or give us a call.

Often same day appointments
No overtime charges
Satisfaction guaranteed
Plumb it Heat it Cool it technician in front of service truck
484-902-2111Book Online