Water Quality

Water Softener vs Water Filter vs Reverse Osmosis: Which Do You Need?

Each system fixes a different problem, and no single one does it all. Match what you are seeing in your water to the system that fixes it.

R
Rob
Owner & Master Plumber
November 16, 20265 min read
Plumb it Heat it Cool it plumber next to a water softener he installed
A water softener we installed in a local home.

The Quick Answer

Pick the system by the problem, not by the sales pitch. Here is the match.

  • Spots on dishes, crust on faucets, dry skin: water softener
  • Pool smell or chlorine taste at every tap: whole-house carbon filter
  • Worried about what is in your drinking water: reverse osmosis at the kitchen sink
  • Rotten egg smell or orange stains on a well: a filter made for well water

What Each One Does

They sound alike. They do very different jobs.

  • Water softener: Takes the hard minerals out of all the water in the house. It stops spots, crust and dry skin, and it protects your water heater. It does not take out chemicals.
  • Whole-house carbon filter: A tank on the main water line. It takes out chlorine taste and smell at every faucet and shower. It does not soften water.
  • Reverse osmosis: A drinking water filter under the kitchen sink with its own faucet. It takes out forever chemicals, lead and other things you cannot see. It treats one tap, not the whole house.

Why No Single System Does It All

Hard minerals, chlorine and forever chemicals are three different kinds of things, and each one takes a different tool to remove. Be careful with any ad for one box that fixes everything. It will do one of those jobs and miss the others.

That is why many homes around here end up with two systems that work together: a softener for the whole house, and a reverse osmosis filter at the kitchen sink for drinking water. Homes with the pool smell add a carbon filter in front of the softener, which also protects the softener.

Not sure which one you need?

We test your water at your home and tell you plainly. One system, two, or none.

Call 484-902-2111Book Online

The Costly Mistake

The most expensive mistake in water treatment is buying a system for a problem you do not have. It happens all the time. Someone buys a softener because they are worried about chemicals, or a fancy filter when their real problem is hard water. They spend the money and the problem is still there.

The fix is simple. Test the water first, then buy only what the test says you need.

Start With a Test

We test your water at your home. We show you the numbers and tell you plainly what they mean. Then we give you the whole price before any work starts.

If the test says you need one system, we will not sell you two. If it says you need nothing, we will tell you that.

Rob and Rachel, owners of Plumb it Heat it Cool it

Hi, we are Rob and Rachel.

We own Plumb it Heat it Cool it, a family-owned company serving Montgomery and Bucks County. Nobody likes calling a plumber. When you call us, we find the problem, show it to you, and give you the whole price before any work starts.

Call 484-902-2111Book Online

Related Services

Water TreatmentWater SoftenersReverse Osmosis
FAQ

Common Questions

Only if you have both problems. A softener handles hard water. A filter handles taste, smell and chemicals. A water test shows which you have.

No. A carbon filter takes out chlorine taste and smell. It does not remove the minerals that make water hard.

Not in the way most people mean. It takes out hard minerals only. It does not remove chlorine, lead or forever chemicals.

There is no single best one. The right system depends on what is in your water, which is why a test comes first.

They do different jobs. Reverse osmosis makes clean drinking water at one sink. A softener protects the whole house from hard water. Many homes have both.

Keep Reading

Related Articles

Water Quality

Do I Need a Water Softener? How They Work and What They Do Not Fix

A softener takes the hard minerals out of your water. It does not take out chemicals. Here is how to tell if you need one, and what it will and will not do.

Read more
Water Quality

Reverse Osmosis Water Filters: What They Remove and Are They Worth It?

A reverse osmosis filter under the kitchen sink gives you clean drinking water from its own small faucet. Here is what it takes out and what to know before you buy one.

Read more
Water Quality

Chloramine in Tap Water: What It Is and How to Filter It

Chloramine is why some tap water smells like a pool. It is harder to filter than chlorine. Here is what works and what does not.

Read more
Ready?

Schedule Your Service Today

Whether it's an emergency or routine maintenance, our team is ready. Book online in 30 seconds or give us a call.

Often same day appointments
No overtime charges
Satisfaction guaranteed
Plumb it Heat it Cool it technician in front of service truck
484-902-2111Book Online