A two-minute test at the sink tells you if the smell is coming from the water heater, the well or the drain. Each one has a different fix.
R
Rob
Owner & Master Plumber
November 16, 20265 min read
Our plumbers on a water heater job in a local basement.
First: Is the Smell in the Water or in the Air?
This matters. Natural gas has a rotten egg smell added to it on purpose so you can smell a leak. If you smell rotten eggs in the room and not just at the faucet, leave the house and call your gas company from outside.
If the smell only shows up when the water runs, keep reading.
The Two-Minute Test
Fill a glass with cold water and carry it to another room. Smell it there. Then do the same with hot water. What you find points to the cause.
The glass does not smell once you walk away: The smell is coming from the drain, not the water.
Only the hot water smells: The cause is in the water heater.
Hot and cold both smell: The cause is in the water coming into the house. This is most common on a well.
Only the Hot Water Smells
Every tank water heater has a metal rod inside that fights rust so the tank does not have to. In some water, that rod reacts with what is in the water and makes a gas that smells like rotten eggs. It is more common on wells and in homes where the hot water has not been used for a while.
The fix is a plumber job. We clean out the tank and swap the rod for a different kind that does not cause the smell. Do not just pull the rod out and leave it out. Without it, the tank rusts through years early.
Hot and Cold Both Smell
If you are on a well, sulfur gas is in the water before it ever reaches the house. It comes from the ground. You will often see black or dark stains on silverware and fixtures along with it.
The fix is a filter made for it, installed where the water comes into the house. The right one depends on how much sulfur there is and what else is in the water, so the water gets tested first.
If you are on town water and both sides smell, call your water company and then call us. That is not normal.
Want the smell gone?
We find where it is coming from, show you, and give you the whole price before any work starts.
If the water in the glass smells fine once you walk away from the sink, the smell is coming up from the drain. Gunk builds up in the pipe under the sink and it stinks when water stirs it up. A sink that does not get used much can also dry out and let sewer smell through.
Run water in drains you do not use often. If one drain keeps smelling, it needs a proper cleaning.
Is It Dangerous?
At the levels found in house water, the sulfur smell is a nuisance more than a danger. It does eat away at metal over time and it stains.
A smell that shows up all of a sudden on a well is worth a test, because it can come along with germs in the water. We test at your home, show you what we found, and give you the whole price before any work starts.
Hi, we are Rob and Rachel.
We own Plumb it Heat it Cool it, a family-owned company serving Montgomery and Bucks County. Nobody likes calling a plumber. When you call us, we find the problem, show it to you, and give you the whole price before any work starts.
The rust-fighting rod inside the water heater is reacting with what is in your water. A plumber can clean the tank and swap the rod for a kind that does not cause the smell.
At the levels found in most homes the smell is a nuisance, not a health danger. A sudden new smell on a well should be tested, because germs can come with it.
With a filter made for sulfur, installed where the water enters the house. The water is tested first so the filter matches what is in it.
No. A softener takes out hard minerals. Sulfur smell needs its own kind of filter.
Water sat in the water heater unused, which gives the smell time to build. Running the hot water for a while often clears it. If it keeps coming back, the tank needs to be cleaned and the rod changed.